Justin Bieber and Hailey threw shade on Instagram, and Selena Gomez joined in with a jab [00:00] - Introduction and Overview of the Controversial Christmas Christmas 2024 caused a real storm between Justin, Hailey, Selena, and Benny. Crisis or marketing strategy? Let’s analyze! [00:52] - The Tumultuous Christmas of Justin and Hailey Justin and Hailey Bieber reportedly threw public jabs at each other on social media with provocative songs. [01:16] - The Meaning Behind Justin's Song Analyzing Justin’s Instagram stories with the song “B.E.D” and fan reactions. [02:02] - Hailey Bieber Responds with SZA Hailey’s posts featuring lyrics from SZA raised even more suspicions about the state of their marriage. [03:23] - Fan Comments [04:08] - Selena Gomez and the Perfect Christmas Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco shared special moments and spread love on social media. [04:48] - Selena and the Alleged Shade Selena’s post sparked speculations about a possible shade directed at Justin and Hailey. [05:21] - Hailey and the Controversial Ring Hailey posts a symbolic ring after Selena’s engagement ring trend, sparking interpretations and comparisons. [06:08] - Hailey Bieber’s Shade Towards Selena Gomez [06:26] - The Second Song Hailey Posted as a Shade to Justin Bieber [07:38] - The Big Question [07:41] - Subscribe, Comment, and Check Out the Playlist with More Jelena Theories!